Skip to content
City PM
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
Saturday 18 March 2017 11:30 am

Gordon Brown has a third “patriotic” option in the debate over a second Scottish independence referendum

By: Rebecca Smith

Add as a preferred source on Google

Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown has an alternative to full-blown independence from the UK, as the debate over a second Scottish referendum ramps up.

During a speech in Fife, Brown suggested giving Holyrood vast new powers, including the responsibility of signing treaties with other European and setting VAT – as long as it stays in the UK.

Read more: Brown: Brexit vote could turn the North into "wastelands"

He deemed the third option "a patriotic Scottish way and free from the absolutism of the SNP and the do-nothing-ism of the Tories" and essential, as post-Brexit realities "make the status quo redundant and require us to break with the past".

Brown spoke at the Festival of Ideas where he also called for the repatriation to Scotland of £800m spent by the EU.

His alternative comes as first minister Nicola Sturgeon increases pressure on Theresa May for a second independence referendum, having said a fresh vote was crucial given June's Brexit vote.

The Scottish National Party leader said the "material change of circumstances" brought about by the Brexit vote justified the repeat of the 2014 referendum, adding "if the Scottish parliament gives me that authority then that should be respected by the UK government."

"The Scottish government's mandate for offering this choice is beyond doubt," Sturgeon said earlier this week in Edinburgh.

In his speech Brown also suggested that the Bank of England change to the Bank of England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, with fully staffed representation in Scotland to emphasise "the fact that the pound is for everyone".

Read more: May 2, Sturgeon nil: The SNP has no case for a second referendum

Brown's compromise, will, he believes, deliver an outcome that suits everyone.

"With these proposed new powers let us send a message today – and I will fight for this in the weeks and months ahead – that from now on the debate on the future of Scotland will no longer be limited to two options," Brown said.

 

Share this article

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email

Similarly tagged content:

Sections

  • News

Categories

  • Business
  • Politics

Trending Articles

  • Burnham tax plans spark investor rush to bank capital gains

  • Nothing fails to file accounts months after dissolution threat

  • I’ve taken the best train trips in the world. Here are my 5 favourites

  • Cruyff turn: Starmer allows pubs to stay open for England World Cup game

  • Nottingham Forest owner Marinakis announces £210m stadium plans

More from City PM

  • Brexit ten years on: my journey from Remain to Leave

    Opinion
    UK Parliament voting on Brexit Leave decision, politicians in debate, capturing pivotal moment in Brexit negotiations
  • Brexit 10 years on: Business does not want a referendum rerun, says CBI chief

    Business
    CBI Chief Economist Newton-Smith addressing economic trends at a business conference podium with charts in the background
  • Mayer Brown defends ‘do not disturb’ policy despite criticism from rivals

    Legal
    Mayer Brown office building exterior with logo, highlighting corporate architecture and professional business environment
  • On this day: Brits vote in referendum that changes everything

    Opinion
    UK flag and EU flag waving side by side, symbolizing Brexit referendum discussions and future political relations.
  • Burnham warns Labour of ‘final chance’ after Makerfield win

    Politics
    Andy Burnham speaking at a Labour Party event, addressing current political issues, with a focused and determined expression.
  • Fractured politics has its upsides – trust me, I led Vote Leave

    Opinion
  • Here’s what a government led by Andy Burnham will look like

    Opinion
    Burnham cityscape featuring historic architecture and bustling streets under clear skies, highlighting urban development.
  • Baillie Gifford in line for Anthropic windfall just months after £3.6bn SpaceX bonanza

    Investing
    Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic, speaking at a tech conference podium, wearing a suit and addressing the audience.

City PM — European politics, business and analysis.

Europe

  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • UK & Ireland

Topics

  • Business
  • Markets
  • AI
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Energy

More

  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Fintech
  • Legal
  • Sport
  • Life

Company

  • About City PM
  • Editorial Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
© 2026 City PM · Published by CityPM Media, Bahnhofstrasse 65, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland
About · Editorial Policy · Corrections · Contact · Privacy