Skip to content
Thursday 23 July 2026London --:--Frankfurt --:--Zurich --:--
NewslettersSearchEN · DE
City PM

European business, markets and politics

FTSE 100
10,702.92
-0.13%
DAX
24,984.25
-0.68%
CAC 40
8,341.84
-1.14%
STOXX 50
6,256.58
-0.96%
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Opinion
More
GermanyFranceBankingAIEnergyFintechPropertyCapital Markets
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • DE
Thursday 15 December 2016 5:53 pm

Fifa’s video replay plans thrown into doubt by critical Real Madrid stars Luka Modric and Cristiano Ronaldo

By: Joe Hall

Add as a preferred source on Google

Fifa's plans to bring video replays into football have been plunged into doubt after Real Madrid stars criticised its use during their 2-0 Club World Cup semi-final win over Mexico's Club America.

Cristiano Ronaldo and Luka Modric blasted the technology currently being trialled by Fifa after the former's injury time goal took nearly a minute to be confirmed while confusion reigned on the pitch.

Ronaldo's celebrations were cut short when Paraguayan referee Enrique Caceres signalled he was checking with a video assistant referee (VAR) whether the goal should stand. 

After initially appearing to wave play on, Caceres then awarded the goal without checking with the replay footage available to him on the side of the pitch — an optional but not compulsory measure available to referees.

Read more: Refs’ chief in plea for video

"It is a new system, even a new event, and I do not like it very much," said former Spurs midfielder Modric.

"That is because I think it can cause a kind of confusion and we have not had it explained to us in too much detail.

"I do not like football with this kind of a system being introduced. I want to focus on the match and play my own football, so my first impression was it's not a good system."

Ronaldo was more direct, saying "the television doesn't work" as he walked off the pitch.


Ronaldo's celebrations were cut short (Source: Getty)

 

In the other semi-final between Japan's Kashima Antlers and Colombians Atletico Nacional, play was pulled back to award a penalty after Viktor Kassai missed an off-the-ball foul, but play was held up for three minutes while he consulted pitch-side videos.

Fifa will have to consider criticism from some of the world's biggest players when consulting with the International Football Association Board (IFAB) about whether to roll out trials internationally.

Writing in City PM, former Premier League referee Howard Webb has warned fans that video replay technology requires serious testing and is unlikely to completely rid incorrect decisions from football.

"Even with the benefit of video we will still get decisions which will split people 50-50 – the technology won’t be a panacea," said Webb.

Real Madrid manager Zinedine Zidane, echoed a similar sentiment after his team's progression to Sunday's final in Yokohama.

"We need to get used to it," he said. "If that is Fifa's policy it is up to us to get used to it. My personal opinion is that it could cause some confusion but Fifa's technical group will make a good decision.

"It could be better as everything could become clearer."

Share this article

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email

Similarly tagged content:

Sections

  • Life&Style

Categories

  • Sport

Related Topics

  • Football

Trending Articles

  • Romesh Ranganathan makes it hard to defend the BBC

  • Tax rises ‘guaranteed’ as Healey faces £22bn black hole from Burnham spending plans

  • Regulator flags BDO’s ‘unacceptable’ audit issues for fifth year in a row 

  • ‘We are going to run out’: Mitie marks eleventh mega takeover of 2026

  • Rachel Reeves’ sister takes top legal role in Burnham’s Cabinet overhaul

More from City PM

  • Why Fifa World Cup players are drowning in commercial red tape

    Sport Business
    GettyImages 2285251650: Business meeting with diverse professionals discussing innovative strategies in a modern office se...
  • Leeds United investor buys majority stake in Spanish football club

    Sport Business
    Happy male soccer player with beard and long hair in white uniform raising arms, smiling
  • Fifa hits back at Trump and Egypt over refereeing bias claims

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo on a modern building facade against a clear blue sky, representing a leading global visual content creator
  • The 2026 World Cup had its flaws, yes, but it was a resounding success for Fifa

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo on a digital display, symbolizing stock photography for news and business publications
  • Fifa accused of bullying in attempt to kill off multi-billion class action claim

    Sport Business
    Getty Images news-related image depicting a significant event or person, suitable for general news and business contexts.
  • Magic circle Linklaters scores FIFA’s top lawyers in US raid

    Legal
    Breaking news event coverage with crowd gathered and reporters, showcasing diverse individuals engaging with media personnel.
  • Calls for Argentina to be banned from World Cup over Falklands banner

    Sport Business
    Business professionals engaged in a collaborative meeting at a conference room discussing strategic growth opportunities
  • Infantino facing IOC probe after complaint lodged over Trump’s Balogun intervention

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo on a smartphone screen, symbolizing stock photography and media resources for news and business websites.
CityPM

Independent European business, markets and political news for decision-makers.

Morning Briefing

Europe

  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • UK & Ireland

Business

  • Markets
  • Banking
  • Technology
  • Energy
  • Property
  • Fintech

Editorial

  • Opinion
  • Editorial Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact

Company

  • About City PM
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
© 2026 City PM Ltd · Published by CityPM Media, Bahnhofstrasse 65, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland
Privacy · Terms · Cookies · Facebook