Skip to content
City PM
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
Tuesday 14 March 2017 5:00 am

Time to dust down the case against the Scottish National Party

By: Christian May

Editor-in-Chief

Add as a preferred source on Google

The pursuit of independence is all that matters to the Scottish Nationalists.

It is the glue that holds together everything they say and do. Having lost the referendum on independence they wasted no time in predicting the circumstances in which another one could follow.

On the day after the EU vote, Sturgeon said that a second Scottish referendum was highly likely, and yesterday she set out exactly how she wishes to achieve it.

Read more: How 5 analysts reacted to Sturgeon's call for another Scottish referendum

Some people say this is purely down to the Leave vote, and to be sure, it has given the SNP perfect cover under which to bring forward plans for a fresh poll, but if it wasn’t Brexit it would have been something else.

Alex Salmond said that a new vote would be likely if Boris Johnson became PM, or if the UK voted to renew its nuclear deterrent.

In other words, they were determined to find a reason and they would have done so at some point in the future. Nevertheless, the UK now faces once again the spectre of disintegration and Brexit will be the soundtrack to the coming battle.

Read more: Sterling sustains strength as Sturgeon signals second Scottish referendum

Sturgeon has likened independence to a lifeboat for Scotland as the Tories sink the rest of the country with their pursuit of a so-called hard Brexit.

In reality, it is membership of the UK that will keep Scotland afloat.

Within hours of her declaration yesterday, the European Commission confirmed that an independent Scotland would have to reapply for EU membership – raising uncomfortable questions about the size of its national debt and the issue of joining the euro.

Read more: New Scottish vote creates uncertainty "at worst possible time" say No10

The SNP’s economic case for independence collapsed along with the oil price, and it’s hard to see how Scotland’s public finances could cope – at least in the short term – with a departure from the UK.

These are the arguments, so recently fought and settled, that now look set to be fought all over again.

While Westminster wrangles with the politics and process of any future vote, the case for the union must be made once again.

In Ruth Davidson, the Scottish Tories have a leader who can make the case better than anyone, but she will need support. A second referendum may be inevitable, but independence is not.

Share this article

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email

Similarly tagged content:

Sections

  • News

Categories

  • Business
  • Politics

Trending Articles

  • Harry Styles at Wembley Stadium review: running through the grief

  • Nottingham Forest owner Marinakis announces £210m stadium plans

  • I’ve taken the best train trips in the world. Here are my 5 favourites

  • Natwest boss becomes latest City figure caught in AI social media scam

  • Exclusive: Top FTSE executive recruiter goes bust after AI platform launch

More from City PM

  • Brexit ten years on: my journey from Remain to Leave

    Opinion
    UK Parliament voting on Brexit Leave decision, politicians in debate, capturing pivotal moment in Brexit negotiations
  • On this day: Brits vote in referendum that changes everything

    Opinion
    UK flag and EU flag waving side by side, symbolizing Brexit referendum discussions and future political relations.
  • Fractured politics has its upsides – trust me, I led Vote Leave

    Opinion
  • Baillie Gifford in line for Anthropic windfall just months after £3.6bn SpaceX bonanza

    Investing
    Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic, speaking at a tech conference podium, wearing a suit and addressing the audience.
  • Is Andy Burnham a left-wing Liz Truss?

    Politics
    Andy Burnham
  • Brexit 10 years on: Business does not want a referendum rerun, says CBI chief

    Business
    CBI Chief Economist Newton-Smith addressing economic trends at a business conference podium with charts in the background
  • Trump blocked from sacking Fed official in landmark Supreme Court ruling

    Politics
  • ‘Not all sunlit uplands’: Pub bosses weigh in on whether Brexit leaves a bitter taste

    Hospitality
    Tim Martin speaking at a business conference, standing at a podium, discussing economic trends and strategies for growth

City PM — European politics, business and analysis.

Europe

  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • UK & Ireland

Topics

  • Business
  • Markets
  • AI
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Energy

More

  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Fintech
  • Legal
  • Sport
  • Life

Company

  • About City PM
  • Editorial Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
© 2026 City PM · Published by CityPM Media, Bahnhofstrasse 65, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland
About · Editorial Policy · Corrections · Contact · Privacy