Weekend read: The SPAC bubble is bursting, argues Syz Bank’s investment chief
With monetary policies tightening, speculative bubbles are bursting one after the other. SPACs are no exception.
As a reminder, a SPAC, or Special Purpose Acquisition Company, is a company with no operational activity – an empty shell – that raises funds on the stock market with the sole objective of making an acquisition or acquisitions.
It asks investors to sign a “blank cheque” with a promise to use the funds raised to acquire an unlisted company in return. Once the deal is completed, the SPAC renames itself after the acquired company, which gets access to the funds raised.
The stock is then traded on the stock exchange like any other listed security. SPACs are therefore “liquid” investment vehicles for obtaining “pre-IPO” shares in high-growth companies.
SPACs offer a major advantage for those aiming for a quick IPO: the financial disclosure requirements are less stringent than for a traditional IPO.
“On the investor side, they have attracted billions of dollars from individuals and hedge funds seeking the higher potential returns, and risks, often associated with private markets,” according to Charles-Henry Monchau, chief investment officer at Syz Bank.
Discussing the SPAC ecosystem with City PM today, Monchau pointed out that the period of massive liquidity injections that was put in place in 2020-2021 in response to the Covid pandemic has played an important role in the exponential growth of SPACs.
“Indeed, these financial securities have been around since the 1990s but their numbers really exploded in popularity in 2020 and the first part of 2021,” he said.
In 2020, no less than 227 transactions worth $76bn were recorded. The year 2021 was even more spectacular: according to Ernst & Young, a total of 646 SPAC transactions were recorded worldwide for a total issue volume of $161bn.
SPAC boom is over
But the SPAC boom seems to be behind us. Indeed, the bubble is bursting, with research firm Audit Analytics reporting that at least 25 companies that merged with SPACs between 2020 and 2021 have issued liquidation warnings in recent months.
“These warnings mean that a company’s auditor has deemed that there is ‘significant doubt’ about the company’s ability to survive the following year,” Monchau explained.
According to Audit Analytics, this is twice the number of warnings issued by companies listed through a traditional initial public offering (IPO).
Companies that have gone public via a SPAC are on average down 60 per cent since the date of issue. The Defiance Next Gen SPAC Derived ETF (SPAK) is down 45 per cent since its June 2021 highs.
Many startups that went public via SPACs now find that their revenue projections at the time of fundraising were in fact far too ambitious.
“The delay in business development leads to significant cash flow problems. This is particularly true for many startups operating in the electric vehicle (EV) sector,” Monchau said.
Electric vehicle sector
Electric Last Mile Solutions (ELMS: Nasdaq), an EV startup that went public in June 2021 through a merger with a SPAC, revealed late last month that it would run out of cash by June.
In February, CEO James Taylor and Chairman Jason Luo, both co-founders, were ousted, with immediate effect, following an internal investigation into share purchases they made just before the company announced its IPO through a merger with a SPAC in December 2020.
Electric Last Mile is under investigation by the SEC. Its auditors decided to throw in the towel in February.
“Since then, the company has not been able to hire a new audit firm and therefore has no one to audit the financial reports it has yet to file,” Monchau pointed out.
In addition, the company has to perform a review of some of the quarterly reports it has already filed. At the end of May, the ELMS share price was down 94 per cent from its peak in June 2021.
“At the rate the company is burning through cash, ELMS is likely to be the first SPAC (in the current cycle) to fall to zero. But it may not be the last,” Monchau said.
Canoo
Startup EV Canoo, which went public via a merger with a SPAC in December 2020, said in its first quarter earnings call that it may not have enough cash to continue operating, adding that “there is significant doubt about the company’s ability to continue as a going concern.”
Monchau recalled that the company is now trying to raise funds by selling $300m in new shares and issuing debt for the same amount.
The company is also under investigation by the SEC regarding its merger with SPAC and its “operations, business model, growth strategy, revenues, customer arrangements and other related matters, as well as the recent departures of certain of the company’s executives.”
“A bit of a boon for class action lawyers… Many executives have left the company, including the co-founders, the CEO, the CFO and the COO. Canoo has still not replaced its CFO and is using an interim CFO,” Monchau said.
At the end of March, Canoo still had $105 million in cash. According to its forecasts, it expects to spend about $200 million in the second quarter while generating no revenue.
“Should Canoo manage to raise the aforementioned $600 million, the company would be able to extend its survival for three more quarters, until the end of 2022 and possibly into 2023,” Monchau said.
“But if Canoo is not able to generate revenue by then, the $600 million raised from investors will be gone and the company would have no choice but to file for bankruptcy.”
According to wolfstreet.com, Canoo does not appear to be in a position to produce a marketable vehicle any time soon. The quarterly loss at the end of March was $125 million.
The company would need billions of dollars from investors – not a few hundred million – in order to accelerate its R&D programme and produce its first vehicles.
“Without this acceleration of development and production, the company has almost no chance of covering its operating expenses,” Monchau noted.
Canoo’s shares have collapsed by 84 per cent from their highs. The issue of new shares will prove to be dilutive and is therefore unlikely to generate a rebound in the stock – at least in the short term.
In another example, Lordstown Motors [RIDE], which went public through a merger with SPAC in October 2020, also filed a “going concern” warning with the SEC. At the end of May, the stock was down 94% from its February 2021 peak.
Electric Last Mile, Canoo and Lordstown Motors are among the 25 SPACs that have issued liquidation warnings. Three other EV companies have issued similar warnings.
“It appears that electric vehicle battery manufacturers may soon add to this list,” Monchau said.
It should be noted that regulators are considering changing the rules on SPACs’ projections and bringing them closer to IPOs, he added.
“The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has said it is considering proposing to limit the legal protections that some SPACs have used in the past when reporting on companies they propose to take public.”
Monchau concluded: “These measures should limit the likelihood of a new speculative bubble in this segment when market conditions become more favourable.”