Skip to content
Thursday 23 July 2026London --:--Frankfurt --:--Zurich --:--
NewslettersSearchEN · DE
City PM

European business, markets and politics

FTSE 100
10,716.97
+1.24%
DAX
25,155.41
0.00%
CAC 40
8,437.89
0.00%
STOXX 50
6,316.99
0.00%
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Opinion
More
GermanyFranceBankingAIEnergyFintechPropertyCapital Markets
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • DE
Monday 21 March 2016 3:42 pm

Budget 2016: John McDonnell says George Osborne should withdraw his Budget as Prime Minister David Cameron stands by the chancellor

By: James Nickerson

Add as a preferred source on Google

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has warned that the Budget process is in "absolute chaos" as the government has withdrawn a large part of the Budget and accepted two opposition amendments before the end of the third day of the budget debate.  

Speaking in the House of Commons, McDonnell asked if the chancellor would make a statement on changes to the Budget, and said "the chancellor insults this House by his refusal to attend".

Given the issues around disability benefits in particular, wouldn't it be "the prudent thing for the chancellor to withdraw this Budget and start again. This is no way to deliver a Budget and no way to manage an economy", McDonnell said.

But David Gauke, financial secretary to the Treasury, responded that the economy is growing faster than other advanced economies. 

Gauke added that the chancellor would be responding tomorrow, before the House votes on the Budget on Wednesday.

Read more: Pound falls after Iain Duncan Smith quits and sparks rumours of Tory civil war

"It’s unacceptable to the country and insulting to parliament that the chancellor is not turning up to respond to my urgent question on the chaos of his making around a Budget he delivered only last week which had collapsed by Friday night," McDonnell said before the question.

The developments come after  now ex-work and pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith quit his role over what he labelled a "deeply unfair" Budget due to its cuts to disability benefits.

And last week it was reported that the government could face a Tory backbench rebellion on the measure. 

Read more: Cameron and Crabb on defensive after IDS resignation

The culmination of events has led to the widely expected climb down on the cuts, which is anticipated to be announced by new work and pensions secretary Stephen Crabb.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister David Cameron said that his government will give the highest priority to improving the life chances of those who live in the UK.

Speaking to the Commons, Cameron said that "everyone in Britain should have the chance to make the most of their lives", adding "we can only improve life chances if our economy is secure and strong".

"Securing our economy, extending opportunity, we will approach with this approach in full because we are a modern, compassionate, one-nation Conservative government," Cameron said.

The statements come as the government gets slammed from all sides of the House of Commons, while the Institute for Fiscal Studies has said that poorer working-age households, especially those with children, will be “hit hard” by the government’s tax and benefits changes while pensioners will be protected.

Share this article

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email

Similarly tagged content:

Sections

  • News

Categories

  • Business
  • Politics

Trending Articles

  • Romesh Ranganathan makes it hard to defend the BBC

  • Tax rises ‘guaranteed’ as Healey faces £22bn black hole from Burnham spending plans

  • Regulator flags BDO’s ‘unacceptable’ audit issues for fifth year in a row 

  • ‘We are going to run out’: Mitie marks eleventh mega takeover of 2026

  • Rachel Reeves’ sister takes top legal role in Burnham’s Cabinet overhaul

More from City PM

  • Tax rises ‘guaranteed’ as Healey faces £22bn black hole from Burnham spending plans

    Economics
    Chancellor John Healey smiling, wearing a navy suit, white shirt, and red tie.
  • Warning for John Healey as key fiscal target missed

    Economics
    Labour MP John Healey in a professional headshot, likely for news or political profile.
  • The seven growth tests every Budget must pass

    Opinion
    Chancellor holding iconic red budget box outside Downing Street, symbolizing UKs annual budget announcement
  • Burnham’s encounter with political and economic reality will be brutal when it comes

    Politics
    Andy Burnham discussing capital gains tax increase during a press conference, highlighting potential economic impacts
  • Unfunded Digital ID will not free up new cash for Burnham’s cost of living plans

    Politics
    Burnham cityscape at sunset with historic buildings and bustling streets, highlighting the vibrant urban landscape
  • Nearly 1m people to pay higher tax ‘by stealth’

    Economics
    Tax Trap: Another 74,000 taxpayers were added to the punitive £100,000-£125,000 income bracket during the 2024/25 tax year
  • We’re being taxed out of existence, companies warn

    Economics
    Rachel Reeves speaking at an IOD event.
  • Four charts revealing scale of Andy Burnham’s economic challenge

    Economics
    Due to the lack of article title, content, categories, and tags, its impossible to create a specific, keyword-rich alt tex...
CityPM

Independent European business, markets and political news for decision-makers.

Morning Briefing

Europe

  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • UK & Ireland

Business

  • Markets
  • Banking
  • Technology
  • Energy
  • Property
  • Fintech

Editorial

  • Opinion
  • Editorial Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact

Company

  • About City PM
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
© 2026 City PM Ltd · Published by CityPM Media, Bahnhofstrasse 65, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland
Privacy · Terms · Cookies · Facebook