Skip to content
City PM
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • Markets
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • DE
Thursday 09 March 2017 5:40 pm

This is the best Scotland side for more than a decade, but they’ve no chance of beating England

This is the best Scotland side we’ve seen for well over a decade, yet I don’t give them any chance of beating England on Saturday and recording their first victory at Twickenham since 1983.

Scotland are playing some good rugby, will pose stern questions and I don’t think for a second that it’ll be a cricket score, but England are the form side in world rugby at the moment. The quality England possess vastly outweighs that of the Scots.

That’s not to take anything away from Scotland. They’ve had two outstanding scalps in Ireland and Wales and are in contention for their maiden Triple Crown since 1990.

Looking back to when Scotland used to enjoy some dominance, the spine of their backline – the No9, 10, 15 axis – was strong. With the likes of Gavin Hastings, Andy Nicol, Gary Armstrong and Gregor Townsend, they had creative talent.

For the first time in ages, Scotland have real threats throughout their backs. Stuart Hogg is an absolute gem of a No15, he’s world class, and Finn Russell and Ali Price are highly impressive. Huw Jones and Alex Dunbar are the best centres they’ve had for a long while.

Weaknesses to exploit

In recent years they've had to rely on turning a game into a dogfight in order to scrape it 10-9 or something like that. Now they have the ability to play some good, free-flowing rugby and cause a lot of problems.

But it’s still not going to be enough at the weekend. England are too strong and looking at the changes head coach Eddie Jones has made, they’re really smart. I believe England will win by a 14-16 point margin.

England will have to weather the storm of a resilient Scotland’s aggression in defence – pressing and harrying – and I reckon it will be tight for around 60 minutes, after which the hosts will pull away.

There are weaknesses for Scotland to exploit, however. While wingers Jack Nowell and Elliot Daly are incredible ball-playing runners, they are quite small.

Scotland had a lot of joy with high balls against the Welsh last month and, considering Harlequins winger Tim Visser is 6ft 3ins, I can imagine that tactic being employed again.

Despite my overall prediction, it is going to be a big test for England’s defence. Scotland have more livewires than Jones’s side have faced so far in the tournament and it will be a prelude to what will be a momentous challenge against Ireland in Dublin next week.

Grand slam-clincher

Perhaps Scotland have also seen how frail England’s decision-making was against Italy during the whole “ruckgate” affair and plan to throw a few curveballs of their own in there. England will need to be a lot smarter than they were against the Azzurri should that happen.

Speaking of Ireland, their match against Wales in Cardiff on Friday is enormous. It will be a cauldron at the Principality Stadium. Whichever way the result goes, it’s going to raise the stakes for England’s potential Grand Slam-clincher in Dublin.

If Ireland win, it will be a straight shootout with England to see who wins the tournament. If Joe Schmidt’s outfit lose, they’ll need to right some wrongs and prove they are a world class team and that win against New Zealand was no fluke. England's clash with Ireland is going to be ferocious.

Ollie Phillips is a former England Sevens captain and now a director at PwC, focusing on organisational, cultural and technological change.

 

 

Share this article

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email

Similarly tagged content:

Sections

  • Life&Style

Categories

  • Sport

Related Topics

  • Rugby Union

Trending Articles

  • Citroën 2CV returns as a £13,000 electric car, and the timing is no accident

  • The former African gold miner taking on the billionaire Issa brothers

  • Wimbledon: HMRC set to slap Sinner and Noskova with £1.6m tax bill

  • Barclays and Lloyds back calls to digitalise UK markets and unlock £33bn boost

  • Music tycoon Simon Cowell sued by prominent City lawyer

More from City PM

  • Will the Nations Championship financially underdeliver for in-need Fiji?

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo displayed prominently on a digital screen, symbolizing the brands visual content prowess and media prese...
  • Reality is rugby’s Nations Championship is botched

    Sport Business
    Business conference attendees engage in discussions at a networking event, featuring diverse professionals in formal attire.
  • Brits urged to back UK pubs during World Cup amid booking surge

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo on a smartphone screen against a blurred background, representing media and stock photo industry branding.
  • Tartan Army cancel flights as Scotland eye a piece of World Cup history

    Sport Business
    Breaking news event concept with diverse people at a business conference discussing innovative strategies and global trends
  • England named most valuable squad at 2026 World Cup, ahead of France and Spain

    Sport Business
    Breaking news concept with typewriter and blank paper on wooden desk, symbolizing journalism and news article creation
  • Dallas, Boston, New York New Jersey: Inside England’s Fifa World Cup stadiums

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo against a sleek, modern background, representing the influence of media in the business world
  • Women’s rugby in England is way ahead, and the RFU deserves credit

    Sport Business
    Breaking news scene with bustling city street, reporters gathering, and onlookers observing, highlighting urban life and m...
  • Do the Prem Rugby semi-finals need a Welsh URC team?

    Sport Business
    Getty Images logo on a digital screen in a business news article context, highlighting media and photography industry.

City PM — European politics, business and analysis.

Europe

  • Germany
  • France
  • Europe
  • UK & Ireland

Topics

  • Business
  • Markets
  • AI
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Energy

More

  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Fintech
  • Legal
  • Sport
  • Life

Company

  • About City PM
  • Editorial Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
© 2026 City PM · Published by CityPM Media, Bahnhofstrasse 65, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland
About · Editorial Policy · Corrections · Contact · Privacy · Facebook